抑郁症的随机对照心理治疗:一项大型的系统综述与元分析
Randomized Controlled Psychotherapy for Depression: A Large-Scale Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
过去几十年来,研究者开发并验证了多种抑郁症心理治疗方法,但这些方法的疗效与具体干预方式和患者类型等之间的关系仍不明确。本研究通过系统综述和元分析,使用METAPSY数据库中的抑郁症:心理治疗与控制子数据,纳入了415项研究,共包含520个效应量,涵盖60127名参与者,评估了八种主要心理治疗方法对抑郁症的有效性。结果显示,心理治疗在缓解抑郁症状方面具有显著效果,综合效应量为0.72。其中,认知行为治疗表现尤为突出。其他如行为激活治疗、第三波认知行为治疗和人际关系治疗也显示出显著效果。此外,对照组类型、地区、抑郁诊断方式、干预形式、招募方式、目标类型和年龄等因素对心理治疗的效果有显著调节作用。尽管存在发表偏倚和异质性问题,但本研究为心理治疗在公共卫生中的应用提供了重要科学依据。
epression is a major global public health challenge and a leading cause of disability related to mental health. The global prevalence of depression is 4.4%, with a 12-month prevalence of 4-5% among adolescents. Depression not only threatens patients education, interpersonal relationships, and career development but is also prospectively associated with early death factors such as obesity, heart disease, and suicide. Various psychological treatments have shown significant effectiveness in alleviating depressive symptoms, improving quality of life, and reducing long-term recurrence rates. These methods include cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), behavioral activation therapy, third-wave cognitive-behavioral therapies, interpersonal therapy, and others. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the gold standard for assessing the efficacy and safety of medical interventions, including psychological treatments. RCTs randomly allocate participants to treatment and control groups, ensuring baseline characteristics are similar across groups, thereby reducing bias and increasing the reliability of the results. Data for the study were sourced from the publicly available METAPSY database. The study included research from 1966 to January 2022. Studies had to be randomized controlled trials and report effect sizes for both psychological treatment and control groups. Inclusion criteria encompassed major depressive disorder, depressive states, and chronic depression. The current study is a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis evaluating the effectiveness of psychological treatments for depression. The study includes 415 research articles, encompassing 520 effect sizes, and involving 60,127 participants. Eight major psychological treatments were assessed, with an overall effect size of 0.72, indicating significant efficacy in alleviating depressive symptoms, particularly cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) which stood out prominently. Other treatments, such as behavioral activation therapy, third-wave cognitive-behavioral therapies, and interpersonal therapy, also demonstrated significant effects. Additionally, factors such as the type of control group, region, method of depression diagnosis, form of intervention, recruitment method, target population, and age significantly moderated the effects of psychological treatments. Despite providing extensive data, the study had some limitations, such as publication bias, broad definitions of depression, and variability in effect assessments. Future research should standardize definitions and evaluation criteria for depression and record therapists professional backgrounds in detail to improve comparability and accuracy. The study confirms the significant role of psychological treatments in managing depression, especially in resource-limited settings, demonstrating considerable therapeutic potential. It provides a scientific basis for the application of psychological treatments in public health and emphasizes the importance of further optimizing and promoting these treatments.
杜峰、胡义秋、曾子豪
神经病学、精神病学医学研究方法
抑郁症心理治疗随机对照试验系统综述元分析
depressionpsychotherapyrandomized controlled trialssystematic reviewsmeta-analysis
杜峰,胡义秋,曾子豪.抑郁症的随机对照心理治疗:一项大型的系统综述与元分析[EB/OL].(2024-11-06)[2025-08-17].https://chinaxiv.org/abs/202411.00108.点此复制
评论