Ubiquitin transfer by a RING E3 ligase occurs from a closed E2~Ub conformation

Abstract Ubiquitination is a eukaryotic post-translational modification that modulates a host of cellular processes1. Modification is mediated by an E1 activating enzyme (E1), an E2 conjugating enzyme (E2) and an E3 ligase (E3). The E1 catalyses formation of a highly reactive thioester linked conjugate between ubiquitin and E2 (E2~Ub)2. The largest class of ubiquitin E3 ligases, which is represented by RING E3s, bind both substrate and E2~Ub and facilitate transfer of ubiquitin from the E2 to substrate. Based on extensive structural analysis3–5 it has been proposed that RING E3s prime the E2~Ub conjugate for catalysis by locking it into a “closed” conformation where ubiquitin is folded back onto the E2 exposing the restrained thioester bond to attack by a substrate nucleophile. However the proposal that the RING dependent closed conformation of E2~Ub represents the active form that mediates ubiquitin transfer is a model that has yet to be experimentally tested. Here we use single molecule F?rster Resonance Energy Transfer (smFRET) to test this hypothesis and demonstrate that ubiquitin is transferred from the closed conformation during an E3 catalysed reaction. Using Ubc13 as an E2, we designed a FRET labelled E2~Ub conjugate, which distinguishes between closed and alternative conformations. Firstly, we defined the high FRET state as the closed conformation using a stable isopeptide linked E2~Ub conjugate, while the low FRET state represents more open conformations. Secondly, we developed a real-time smFRET assay to monitor RING E3 catalysed ubiquitination with a thioester linked E2~Ub conjugate and determined the catalytically active conformation. Our results demonstrate that the reaction proceeds from the high FRET or closed conformation and confirm the hypothesis that the closed conformation is the active form of the conjugate. These findings are not only relevant to RING E3 catalysed ubiquitination but are also broadly applicable to E3 mediated ligation of other ubiquitin-like proteins (Ubls) to substrates.