Diverse digital and fuzzy composite transcriptional elements are prevalent features of mammalian cis-regulomes

Abstract Mammalian transcriptional regulatory sequences are comprised of complex combinations of simple transcription factor (TF) motifs. Stereospecific juxta-positioning of simple TF motifs generates composite elements (CEs), that increase combinatorial and regulatory specificity of TF-DNA interactions. Although a small number of CEs and their cooperative or anti-cooperative modes of TF binding have been thoroughly characterized, a systematic analysis of CE diversity, prevalence and properties in cis-regulomes has not been undertaken. We developed a computational pipeline termed CEseek to discover >20,000 CEs in open chromatin regions of diverse immune cells and validated many using CAP-SELEX, ChIP-Seq and STARR-seq datasets. Strikingly, the CEs manifested a bimodal distribution of configurations, termed digital and fuzzy, based on their stringent or relaxed stereospecific constraints, respectively. Digital CEs mediate cooperative as well as anti-cooperative binding of structurally diverse TFs that likely reflect AND/OR genomic logic gates. In contrast, fuzzy CEs encompass a less diverse set of TF motif pairs that are selectively enriched in p300 associated, multi-genic enhancers. The annotated CEs greatly expand the regulatory DNA motif lexicon and the universe of TF-TF interactions that underlie combinatorial logic of gene regulation.