Spotlight on 10x Visium: a multi-sample protocol comparison of spatial technologies

Background: Spatial transcriptomics allows gene expression to be measured within complex tissue contexts. Among the array of spatial capture technologies available is 10x Genomics' Visium platform, a popular method which enables transcriptome-wide profiling of tissue sections. Visium offers a range of sample handling and library construction methods which introduces a need for benchmarking to compare data quality and assess how well the technology can recover expected tissue features and biological signatures. Results: Here we present SpatialBench, a unique reference dataset generated from spleen tissue of mice responding to malaria infection spanning several tissue preparation protocols (both fresh frozen and FFPE samples, with and without CytAssist tissue placement). We noted better quality control metrics in reference samples prepared using probe-based capture methods, particularly those processed with CytAssist, validating the improvement in data quality produced with the platform. Our analysis of replicate samples extends to explore spatially variable gene detection, the outcomes of clustering and cell deconvolution using matched single-cell RNA-sequencing data and publicly available reference data to identify cell types and tissue regions expected in the spleen. Multi-sample differential expression analysis recovered known gene signatures related to biological sex or gene knockout. Conclusions: We framed a comprehensive multi-sample analysis workflow that allowed us to generate consistent results both within and between different subsets of replicate samples, enabling broader comparisons and interpretations to be made at the group-level. Our SpatialBench dataset, analysis, and workflow can serve as a practical guide for Visium users and may prove valuable in other benchmarking studies.