Escape from X-inactivation in twins exhibits intra- and inter-individual variability across tissues and is heritable

ABSTRACT X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) silences one X-chromosome in female cells to balance sex-differences in X-dosage. A subset of X-linked genes escape XCI, but the extent to which this phenomenon occurs and how it varies across tissues and in a population is as yet unclear. In order to characterize the incidence and variability of escape across individuals and tissues, we conducted a large scale transcriptomic study of XCI escape in adipose, skin, lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) and immune cells in 248 twins drawn from a healthy population cohort. We identify 159 X-linked genes with detectable escape, of which 54 genes, including 19 lncRNAs, were not previously known to escape XCI. Across tissues we find a range of tissue-specificity, with 11% of genes escaping XCI constitutively across tissues and 24% demonstrating tissue-restricted escape, including genes with cell-type specific escape between immune cell types (B, T-CD4+, T-CD8+ and NK cells) of the same individual. Escape genes interact with autosomal-encoded proteins and are involved in varied biological processes such as gene regulation. We find substantial variability in escape between individuals. 49% of genes show inter-individual variability in escape, indicating escape from XCI is an under-appreciated source of gene expression differences. We utilized twin models to investigate the role of genetics in variable escape. Overall, monozygotic (MZ) twin pairs share more similar escape than dizygotic twin pairs, indicating that genetic factors underlie differences in escape across individuals. However, we also identify instances of discordant XCI within MZ co-twin pairs, suggesting that environmental factors also influence escape. Thus, XCI escape may be shaped by an interplay of genetic factors with tissue- and cell type-specificity, and environment. These results illuminate an intricate phenotype whose characterization aids understanding the basis of variable trait expressivity in females.