Natural variants in C. elegans atg-5 3’UTR uncover divergent effects of autophagy on polyglutamine aggregation in different tissues

Abstract Diseases caused by protein misfolding and aggregation, in addition to cell selectivity, often exhibit variation among individuals in the age of onset, progression, and severity of disease. Genetic variation has been shown to contribute to such clinical variation. We have previously found that protein aggregation-related phenotypes in a model organism, C. elegans, can be modified by destabilizing polymorphisms in the genetic background and by natural genetic variation. Here, we identified a large modifier locus in a Californian wild strain of C. elegans, DR1350, that alters the susceptibility of the head muscle cells to polyglutamine (polyQ) aggregation, and causes an increase in overall aggregation, without changing the basal activity of the muscle proteostasis pathways known to affect polyQ aggregation. We found that the two phenotypes were genetically separable, and identified regulatory variants in a gene encoding a conserved autophagy protein ATG-5 (ATG5 in humans) as being responsible for the overall increase in aggregation. The atg-5 gene conferred a dosage-dependent enhancement of polyQ aggregation, with DR1350-derived atg-5 allele behaving as a hypermorph. Examination of autophagy in animals bearing the modifier locus indicated enhanced response to an autophagy-activating treatment. Because autophagy is known to be required for the clearance of polyQ aggregates, this result was surprising. Thus, we tested whether directly activating autophagy, either pharmacologically or genetically, affected the polyQ aggregation in our model. Strikingly, we found that the effect of autophagy on polyQ aggregation was tissue-dependent, such that activation of autophagy decreased polyQ aggregation in the intestine, but increased it in the muscle cells. Our data show that cryptic genetic variants in genes encoding proteostasis components, although not causing visible phenotypes under normal conditions, can have profound effects on the behavior of aggregation-prone proteins, and suggest that activation of autophagy may have divergent effects on the clearance of such proteins in different cell types.