Evolution of the canonical sex chromosomes of the guppy and its relatives

Abstract The sex chromosomes of the guppy, Poecilia reticulata, and its close relatives are of particular interest: they are much younger than the highly degenerate sex chromosomes of model systems such as mammals and Drosophila melanogaster, and they carry many of the genes responsible for the males’ dramatic coloration. Over the last decade, several studies have analyzed these sex chromosomes using a variety of approaches including sequencing genomes and transcriptomes, cytology, and linkage mapping. Conflicting conclusions have emerged, in particular concerning the history of the sex chromosomes and the evolution of suppressed recombination between the X and Y. Here we address these controversies by reviewing the evidence and reanalyzing data. We find no support for a nonrecombining sex determining region (SDR) or evolutionary strata in P. reticulata. We confirm that its congener P. picta has evolved dosage compensation across all of its X chromosome. Last, we do not find evidence that the nonrecombining SDRs of P. picta and P. wingei descend from a common ancestral SDR, and suggest instead that suppressed recombination between the X and Y evolved independently after the two species diverged. We identify possible causes of conflicting results in previous studies and suggest best practices going forward.