继发性良性阵发性位置性眩晕的临床特征及心理因素对复位后残余症状的影响研究
linical Characteristics of Secondary Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo and the Influence of Psychological Factors on Residual Symptoms After Reduction
背景??良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)是以具有自限性、易反复发作为特点的临床常见病,手法复位治疗可以取得较好疗效,复位后部分患者会出现残余症状。近年来对BPPV治疗效果影响因素的研究较多,但对具体病因间的治疗效果比较及残余症状发生的影响因素仍有待探讨。目的 ?分析继发性BPPV的临床特征,探讨BPPV的病因分类对疾病复发率的影响,及BPPV复位后发生残余症状的影响因素。方法 ?选取2019年4月—2021年4月就诊于吉林大学第一医院耳鼻咽喉头颈外科眩晕门诊及耳内科住院患者中确诊为BPPV的患者共340例,患者均同意行手法复位治疗。按是否存在原发病将患者分为原发性BPPV(原发组)、继发性BPPV(继发组)。继发组再按病因的不同分为5个亚组,主要病因包括突发性聋(SSNHL)、前庭性偏头痛(VM)、梅尼埃病(MD)、前庭神经炎(VN)、其他(如颅脑及耳部手术、Hunt综合征、颞骨骨折等)。比较原发组、继发组之间的临床特征及预后情况。随访至首次复位后3个月,再按患者随访期内有无残余症状发生将患者分为出现残余症状组、未出现残余症状组。比较两组间临床特征及不同时段(诊断时、治疗后4周、治疗后3个月)焦虑自评量表(SAS)、抑郁自评量表(SDS)评分的差异,分析BPPV复位后发生残余症状的独立影响因素。结果 ?340例患者中,原发组184例(54.1%)、继发组156例(45.9%)。继发组较原发组发病患者年龄小,经2次以上复位治疗所占比例高,一次复位成功率低,3个月内复发率、残余症状发生率、诊断时SAS评分、诊断时SDS评分高,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。继发性BPPV患者中不同病因患者年龄比较,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);其中其他(如颅脑及耳部手术、Hunt综合征、颞骨骨折等)病因患者年龄小于SSNHL、VM、MD、VN患者(P<0.05)。继发性BPPV患者中不同病因患者性别、受累半规管、复位次数、一次复位成功率、3个月内复发率、残余症状发生率及各时段SAS、SDS评分比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。首次复位后3个月,出现残余症状组133例,未出现残余症状组207例。残余症状主要表现为头部昏沉感(59.4%,79/133)、不稳感(24.06%,32/133)及头颈部不适(9.77%,13/133),出现两种及以上症状者占6.77%(9/133)。出现残余症状组继发性病因所占比例、复位次数>2次所占比例高于未出现残余症状组(P<0.05);出现残余症状组伴随疾病复发所占比例少于未出现残余症状组,诊断时、治疗后4周、治疗后3个月SAS、SDS评分高于未出现残余症状组(P<0.01)。多因素Logistic回归分析结果显示,诊断时SAS评分(OR=1.231,95%CI=1.117~1.357,P<0.001)、SDS评分(OR=1.209,95%CI=1.113~1.314,P<0.001)是BPPV患者复位后残余症状发生的危险因素。结论 ?继发性BPPV具有复位后残余症状发生率较高、复发率高的特点,焦虑、抑郁情绪会影响复位后残余症状的发生。
Background??Benign paroxysmal positional vertigoBPPVis a common clinical disease characterized by self-limiting and easy recurrence. Manual reduction is effective but residual symptoms may occur in some patients after reduction. In recent yearsthere are many studies focus on the influencing factors of therapeutic efficiency of BPPVwhile the comparison among specific causes and factors influencing residual symptoms remain to be further investigated. Objective ?To analyze the clinical features of secondary BPPVinvestigate the effect of etiological classification of BPPV on the recurrence rateand clarify the risk factors of residual symptoms after BPPV reduction. Methods??A total of 340 patients diagnosed with BPPV were enrolled in the vertigo clinic of the department of otorhinolaryngology head and neck surgery department and otology department of the First Hospital of Jilin University from April 2019 to April 2021and all of them agreed to manual reduction. The included patients were divided into the primary BPPVthe primary groupand secondary BPPVthe secondary groupgroups according to the presence or absence of primary disease. The secondary group was further divided into five subgroups according to different etiologiesincluded sudden sensorineural hearing lossSSNHLvestibular migraineVMMénière diseaseMDvestibular neuritisVNand otherssuch as cranial and ear surgeryHunt syndrometemporal bone fractureetc.. The clinical features and prognosis were compared between the primary group and secondary group. Follow-up to 3 months after the first reductionthe patients were divided into the residual symptom group and non-residual symptom group according to the occurrence of residual symptoms. The differences were compared in clinical characteristics and scores of Self-rating Anxiety ScaleSASand Self-rating Depression ScaleSDSat different time periodsat diagnosis4 weeks after treatmentand 3 months after treatmentbetween the two groupsand the independent risk factors of residual symptoms after BPPV reduction were analyzed. Results??Among the 340 patients18454.1%were in the primary group and 15645.9%were in the secondary group. Compared with the primary groupthe patients of the secondary group was youngerand the proportion of patients who underwent more than two reductions was higherthe success rate of the first reduction was lowerand the recurrence rate within 3 monthsincidence of residual symptomsSAS score at diagnosisand SDS score at diagnosis in the primary group were higher than those in the secondary groupwith significant differencesP<0.05. There were statistically significant differences in the age of patients with different etiologies of secondary BPPVP<0.05and the age of patients with other etiologiessuch as cranial and ear surgeryHunt syndrometemporal bone fractureetc.was lower than that of patients with SSNHLVMMDand VN groupsP<0.05. There were no significant differences in gendersemicircular canal involvementnumber of reductionssuccess rate of the first reductionrecurrence rate within 3 monthsincidence of residual symptomsSAS and SDS scores at different time among different etiology groups of secondary BPPVP>0.05. There were 133 patients in residual symptom group and 207 patients in the non-residual symptom group. The main residual symptoms were dizziness59.4%79/133instability24.06%32/133and head and neck discomfort9.77%13/133and 6.77%9/133had two or more symptoms. The proportion of secondary BPPV and more than two reductions in the residual symptom group was higher than that in the non-residual symptom groupP<0.05and the proportion of recurrence was lessthe SAS and SDS scores at diagnosis4 weeks after treatmentand 3 months after treatment were higher than those in the non-residual symptom groupP<0.01.The results of multivariate Logistic regression analysis showed that SAS score at diagnosisOR=1.23195%CI=1.117-1.357P<0.001and SDS score at diagnosisOR=1.20995%CI=1.113-1.314P<0.001were risk factors for the occurrence of residual symptoms after reduction in BPPV patients. Conclusion??Secondary BPPV is characterized by a high incidence of residual symptoms and recurrence rate after reduction. The anxiety and depression can affect the occurrence of residual symptoms after reduction.
于红、王倩、周昕阳、于书剑
10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2023.0569
临床医学耳鼻咽喉科学神经病学、精神病学
良性阵发性位置性眩晕前庭疾病残余症状心理因素影响因素分析
于红,王倩,周昕阳,于书剑.继发性良性阵发性位置性眩晕的临床特征及心理因素对复位后残余症状的影响研究[EB/OL].(2024-01-11)[2025-08-19].https://chinaxiv.org/abs/202401.00174.点此复制
评论