|国家预印本平台
首页|认知本体论: 构建心理构念的统一框架

认知本体论: 构建心理构念的统一框架

ognitive Ontology: A Unified Framework for Psychological Constructs

中文摘要英文摘要

p>构念(Construct)是研究者对其研究对象进行表征形成的抽象概念,是研究者与同行交流的核心载体。在科学心理学中,构念的本体论承诺&mdash;&mdash;某构念能否反映特定客观实体&mdash;&mdash;一直较少受到关注。科学心理学中对构念的定义和测量缺乏统一的规范,用于表征心理构念的概念之间关系混乱,不同研究对构念进行探索的异同之处难以被清晰地辨析,导致研究者难以对已经发表的结果进行整合,阻碍了科学心理学的理论进步。要解决这一问题,科学心理学需要建构基于共识的认知本体论(Cognitive&nbsp; Ontology)框架,梳理心理构念与心理实体(Psychological Entity)之间的映射关系。认知本体论回答如下两个问题:(1)作为科学心理学的研究对象是什么;(2)如何建立关于科学心理学研究对象的知识大厦?本文指出,基于当前科学界的共识&mdash;&mdash;演化论,科学心理学的研究对象应当是人类的心理能力(Psychological Capacity),即人类的演化过程中形成的适应性功能。对心理能力的实证研究需要通过形式化和数学化模型,建立&ldquo;心理能力-构念-测量-数据&rdquo;的逻辑链条,并在研究者间形成共识。现阶段,研究者需通过元研究对心理构念现有的操作化定义/测量进行汇总、分析和评估,并对这些测量进行大规模施测,形成关于该构念及其测量的大数据集;在大数据集的基础上,进行数据驱动和理论驱动的计算建模,以厘清各种测量间关系,更新关于该构念及相关构念的测量模型和理论模型,筛选和迭代对该构念的测量手段。通过研究者间的合作,不断迭代以上过程,积累数据、更新关于心理构念的测量模型与理论模型,推动科学心理学在知识的积累中实现理论上的突破。</p

p>A construct is a concept proposed by a researcher to represent an object of interest. Constructs serve as core media for scientific communication in research. In psychological science, the ontological commitment of constructs - whether a construct reflects a particular ontological entity - has received less attention. However, the progress of psychological science is compromised by three issues related to ontological commitments of constructs: the lack of a unified framework for defining and measuring psychological constructs, the confusion of ontological relations of psychological constructs, and the difficulty in identifying the similarities and deviations among different psychological constructs. We propose that one potential solution to the predicament is a consensus-based cognitive ontology framework that sort out the mapping relationship between psychological constructs and psychological entities. Cognitive ontology aims at answering the following questions: (1) what is the object of psychological science; and (2) how to accumulate the knowledge in the field? We suggest that based on evolutionary theory, psychological science should take human&#39;s psychological capacity, which is shaped by evolution, as the object of its study. Empirical studies of psychological capacity should be conducted under a consensus-based framework that provides a coherent logical flow from &quot;psychological capacity&rdquo; to &ldquo;construct&rdquo;, &ldquo;measurement&rdquo;, and &ldquo;data&quot;, via mathematical or formal models. To build this framework, researchers need meta-science to re-evaluate the existing operationalization/measurements of psychological constructs; large-scale datasets from massive data collection using all available operationalization/measurements obtained in meta-science; and models, data-driven and/or theory-driven, to specify the relationships among measurements. By doing so, researchers will be able to update the measurement and theoretical models of the target construct and its related constructs. Iterating the above process, with the collaboration among researchers, the field as a whole will continue updating the measurements and theoretical models of its constructs, accumulating data, and, eventually, accelerating theoretical breakthroughs in psychological science.</p

10.12074/202301.00098V1

科学、科学研究

认知本体论心理能力心理构念元研究测量理论

cognitive ontologypsychological capacitypsychological constructmeta-sciencemeasurementmodels theory

.认知本体论: 构建心理构念的统一框架[EB/OL].(2023-01-10)[2025-08-02].https://chinaxiv.org/abs/202301.00098.点此复制

评论