领域前沿识别方法综述
Review of the Main Recognition Methods of Frontier Research
[目的/意义]通过比较分析不同的领域前沿识别方法,总结各类方法在识别与预测前沿上的优缺点,为未来研究前沿的识别与预测提出改进意见。[方法/过程]通过综述国内外研究前沿相关的文献,辨析研究前沿的相关概念。分析目前主要的研究前沿识别方法,相较于传统的识别方法,重点对变革性研究前沿的识别方法进行归纳。总结当前领域前沿识别方法存在的主要问题,并提出改进建议。[结果/结论]就概念而言,对“研究热点”、“新兴研究”和“研究前沿”的概念内涵在时间和创新程度两个维度上进行了区分,依据创新程度的不同,研究前沿可以分为“常规性研究前沿”和“变革性研究前沿”;就识别方法而言,不同方法都有其适用场景。未来需要深入挖掘“研究前沿”,尤其要关注到主题之间的语义关联和多源数据的多元关系融合,以及对“变革性研究前沿”的前期征兆进行特征挖掘,并构建相应的识别与预测方法。
Purpose/significance] This paper summarized the advantages and disadvantages of various recognition methods of frontier researches by comparing and analyzing these methods, and suggested improvements for future researches.[Method/process] Firstly, it reviewed the literatures related to research frontiers at home and abroad, and identified relevant concepts of the research frontier. Then, the paper analyzed the main exsited research methods for the identification of research frontiers. Comparing with the traditional identification methods, this paper emphasized the summary of recognition methods of transformative research frontiers. Finally, this study summarized the main problems existed in the frontier identification methods, and put forward suggestions for improving the research frontier identification methods.[Result/conclusion] In terms of conceptual meanings, this paper distinguished research hotspots, emerging researches and research frontiers in the dimensions of time and innovation. According to the different levels of innovation, research frontiers can be divided into conventional research frontiers and transformative research frontiers. In terms of identification methods, different methods have their own applicable scenes. In the future, it is necessary to further dig out the measurement features of the "research frontier", especially the semantic associations among topics and the fusion of multiple relations should be focused on, as well as the feature mining of the early signs of "transformation research frontier", and then constructing corresponding recognition and prediction methods.
许海云、董坤、罗瑞
自然科学研究方法科学、科学研究
领域前沿研究前沿变革性创新新兴研究主题识别
forefrontsresearch frontiertransformative innovationemerging researchtopic recognition
许海云,董坤,罗瑞.领域前沿识别方法综述[EB/OL].(2023-08-27)[2025-08-05].https://chinaxiv.org/abs/202308.00471.点此复制
评论