科技期刊初审效率提升策略--基于投稿日周内效应的研究
he strategy to improve the efficiency of initial evaluation of sci-tech journals--A study based on day-of-the-week effect of submission day
挖掘人工智能对期刊大数据识别和利用的方式,针对人工智能编辑和传统编辑模式的协同工作管理模式,调整期刊审稿方式,提高稿件初审效率。通过作者向本刊投稿行为的研究,找出投稿行为中是否存在某种非强制性的规律和文章的关系,对2017年11月28日-2019年11月28日(即2年,731d)向本刊投稿系统提交的论文数据进行分析,提供卡方等统计检验以确保结果的有效性,在熵的背景下提出了热力学联系,用熵距离度量提交过程的无序性,对录用数量,录用率,拒稿数量,拒稿率,排斥率进行比较,用L值对投稿日进行检验和排序。提出了一种新的对周内投稿日有侧重的审稿策略,有效地提高了初审效率。作为人工智能利用大数据深度学习的一种新的数据利用模式。此策略在大数据+人工智能时代出版模式为编辑快速筛选文章提供的一种新方式,将为出版流程注入更多的活力,使其更容易发现优质文章。
Explore the ways of artificial intelligence to identify and utilize the big data of journals, adjust the way of journal manuscript review and improve the efficiency of manuscript initial evaluation according to the collaborative work management mode of artificial intelligence editing and traditional editing mode. Through the study of the author\'s submission behavior to academic journals, this paper finds out whether there is some kind of non-mandatory law in the submission behavior and the relationship between the quality of the articles, so as to provide reference for related theoretical research and academic journals. The paper submitted to the submission system of Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology from November 28, 2017 to November 28, 2019 (i.e. 2 years, 731d) was analyze. Statistical tests such as chi-square are provided to ensure the validity of the results. Thermodynamic relations are proposed in the context of entropy, and entropy distance is used to measure the disorder of the submission process. The number of offers, the rate of offers, the number of rejected offers, the rate of rejected offers and the rate of rejected offers were compared. L value is used to check and sort the submission day. This paper puts forward a new paper review strategy which focuses on the submission day within a week, which effectively improves the efficiency of the initial evaluation.As a new data utilization model of deep learning with big data by artificial intelligence. This strategy provides a new way for editors to quickly screen articles in the era of big data and artificial intelligence, which will inject more vitality into the publishing process and make it easier to find high-quality articles.
刘天浩
信息传播、知识传播科学、科学研究计算技术、计算机技术
初审效率周内效应投稿日同行评议熵卡方
efficiency of initial evaluationDay-of-the-week effectsubmission daypeer reviewentropychi-square
刘天浩.科技期刊初审效率提升策略--基于投稿日周内效应的研究[EB/OL].(2020-03-05)[2025-08-16].http://www.paper.edu.cn/releasepaper/content/202003-42.点此复制
评论