松嫩平原盐碱地不同植物种植对土壤理化性质、肥力指标与细根生长的影响及在不同土壤深度的表现差异
Effects of different plants cultivation on soil physical and chemical properties, soil fertilities, fine root growth and their differences among different soil depths in saline-alkaline soils in Songnen Plain, northeastern China
不同土地利用如何影响土壤理化性质及其作用深度一直是土壤生态学的研究热点,但是对松嫩平原地区退化盐碱地相关研究匮乏,直接影响生产实践活动。为此,本文以肇东实验林场为研究对象,对8种植物类型(农田、草地、杨树、落叶松、水曲柳、榆树、樟子松、黄檗)的三个土壤深度(0-20cm、20-40cm、40-60cm)进行采样,共测定根系密度、根系含水量、土壤含水量、容重、电导率、pH值、有机碳、全氮、碱解氮、全磷、速效磷、全钾、速效钾等13个指标,并进行多因素方差分析,旨在探讨松嫩平原盐碱地不同植物种植对土壤理化性质、肥力指标与细根生长的影响并确认在不同土壤深度的表现差异。大多数指标如根系密度、pH、土壤容重、有机碳含量、碱解氮含量、全氮含量,全磷含量、速效钾含量、全钾含量出现随深度显著变化,但是这并没有显著影响种间差异的发现:不同植被对13个土壤指标的7个(根系密度、pH值、速效磷、土壤含水量、土壤电导率、有机碳、全氮)具有显著影响,而对其余6个指标多没有影响,7个指标中前3个指标在0-60cm不同土层的种间差异显著不同(交互作用,p < 0.05),而剩余4个指标在60cm土壤剖面不同土层的种间差异一致(交互作用,p > 0.05)。具体表现为:草地土壤含水量显著高于其它植物类型,而农田和水曲柳次之,草地是落叶松的1.8倍;土壤pH草地最高达到8.75,明显高于多数林地和农田;草地土壤的电导率为503.4μS/m显著大于其它各植物类型的土壤电导率,而其它各个树种、农田间差异不显著;这些结果说明,盐碱地造林能够降低土壤盐碱度,但是往往要消耗更多的土壤水分。水曲柳根系密度是草地的1.27倍,是落叶松和樟子松的1.75倍,其它植物间无显著差异;而且杨树、樟子松的有机碳含量显著低于黄檗、榆树、草地和水曲柳;说明在松嫩平原盐碱化草地上造林没有增加土壤碳的细根土壤输入、也没有导致土壤SOC的累积。此外,草地全氮含量最高为1.12g/kg,显著高于农田、落叶松、杨树、樟子松,而最低者樟子松和杨树林仅为最高者的72.3%;速效磷含量黄檗(3.39mg/kg)和草地(2.27mg/kg)显著高于水曲柳(1.24mg/kg)和落叶松(1.01mg/kg),而其它植被居中、没有显著差异;所有其它养分包括全P、全K和速效K不同植被间没有显著差异;这说明不同植被(农田、草地和造林)之间对土壤养分消耗没有显著的差别。此外,交互作用(植被类型*土壤深度)分析还发现,根系含水量在不同层土壤(0-20cm,20-40cm,40-60cm)上的种间差异是不一致的(p < 0.05),而这种不一致可能导致其在整体数据(不同层)种间差异不显著(p > 0.05)。上述结果说明,与原有植被草地相比,松嫩平原盐碱化土壤造林虽然能降低盐碱化,但对土壤养分消耗相差不大,需要注意是造林对水分消耗更大以及对不同层土壤影响程度的差异。这些发现可为今后该地区种间差异比较、土壤肥力评价、土壤养分收支平衡等研究提供指导。
he effects of different land uses on soil properties and its functioning depth are prevailing hotspots in soil ecology, but few researches is available in saline-alkaline soil, in Songnen Plain, northeastern China. Taking the Zhaodong Experimental Forest Farm as the research site, three soil layers (0-20cm, 20-40cm, 40-60cm) from 8 vegetation types (grassland, farmland, plantations of ash, elm, poplar, mongolian pine, amur corktree, larch ) were sampled and 13 soil parameters (root density, root water, soil moisture, pH, electrical conductance (EC), soil bulk density, soil organic carbon (SOC), alkaline-N, total N, available-P, total P, available-K , total K) were measured. By using vegetation types and soil depths as independent factors, a MANOVA (multivariate analysis of variance) was used for finding the effects of different plants cultivation on soil properties and fine root growth and their differences in different soil depths. Most parameters (root density, pH, bulk density, SOC, alkaline-N, total N, total P, available-K, total K) showed significant change with soil depths. Seven out of the 13 parameters (root density, pH, available-P, soil moisture, EC, SOC, total N) were significantly influenced by different plants. Of the seven parameters, interspecies differences of the first three parameters varied at different soil layers, while the other 4 parameters showed similar interspecies differences among whole soil profile. Peak soil moisture was found in grassland, followed by farmland and ash plantation, and soil moisture in grassland was 1.8 times higher than that in larch plantation; soil pH in grassland (8.75) was significantly higher than those in the most woodland and farmland; EC in grassland (503.4μS/m) was significantly greater than those in all the other vegetation types. Root density in ash plantation was respectively 1.27 and 1.75 times higher than those in grassland and plantations of larch and mongolian pine. SOC in plantations of poplar, mongolian pine were significantly lower than those in plantations of amur corktree, elm, ash and grassland ; Both results of root density and SOC indicate that afforestation in saline-alkalization grassland can neither increase soil carbon input by fine roots, nor in SOC accumulation. Soil total N in grassland, 1.12g/kg, was significantly higher than those in farmland, plantations of larch, poplar and mongolian pine; available-P in amur corktree plantation (3.39mg/kg) and grassland (2.27mg/kg) were significantly higher than those in ash plantation (1.24mg/kg) and larch plantation (1.01mg/kg). No differences were observed in all the other nutrients (total P, total K and available-K) among different plants; these nutrient differences suggest that no differences on soil nutrients depletion were observed among different plants (farmland, grassland and afforestation). A further interaction analysis (vegetation types * soil depths) found that interspecific differences of root water were different in different soil layers (p<0.05). All above mentioned results manifest that afforestation with proper species in Songnen Plain could reduce soil salinity-alkalinity with the expense of more water consumption and similar soil nutrients depletion. Our findings provide guidance both for local afforestation and researches of comparison of region interspecies differences, evaluation of soil fertility, soil nutrient balance in the future.
任蔓莉、王琼、魏晨辉、裴忠雪、路嘉丽、王文杰、沈光
农业科学研究环境科学基础理论植物学
土壤理化性质植物类型土壤深度盐碱地改良土地利用方式树种差异
Soil physical and chemical propertiesvegetation typessoil depthssaline-alkaline soil improvementland usestree species variationy
任蔓莉,王琼,魏晨辉,裴忠雪,路嘉丽,王文杰,沈光.松嫩平原盐碱地不同植物种植对土壤理化性质、肥力指标与细根生长的影响及在不同土壤深度的表现差异[EB/OL].(2014-05-06)[2025-08-19].http://www.paper.edu.cn/releasepaper/content/201405-66.点此复制
评论