|国家预印本平台
首页|反馈信息类型与效价对公众科学志愿者参与表现激励效应的实验研究

反馈信息类型与效价对公众科学志愿者参与表现激励效应的实验研究

Research on the Motivational Impact of the Type and Valence of Feedback Information on Volunteer Performance in Citizen Science Projects

中文摘要英文摘要

目的/意义] 提供反馈是一项增强用户动机和参与的重要设计。研究反馈信息对公众科学志愿者参与表现的激励效应,为改进公众科学项目的反馈信息设计及提高志愿者参与表现提供指导和建议。[方法/过程] 基于反馈干预理论框架,结合社会认知理论和沉浸理论,构建反馈类型及反馈效价对公众科学项目志愿者的参与体验及参与表现的影响因素理论模型,并探讨反馈类型与反馈效价的交互作用。实证采用2(反馈类型:描述型vs.评价型)×2(反馈效价:积极vs.消极)组间实验进行模型验证。[结果/结论] 分析结果表明,在公众科学项目中,反馈类型与反馈效价对志愿者参与体验的影响存在差异,即志愿者在评价型反馈中比描述型反馈有更高的自我效能感;在积极反馈中比消极反馈有更高的自我效能感及沉浸体验。反馈类型与反馈效价对自我效能感具有交互效应,在消极反馈中,志愿者在评价型反馈中比描述型反馈有更高的自我效能。志愿者的参与体验对参与表现有正向的影响作用。

Purpose/significance] Providing feedback is an important design to motivate volunteers and enhance their participation. This research aims to study the motivational impact of feedback information on volunteers' participation performance, in order to provide guidance and suggestions for designing citizen science project and improving volunteers' performance.[Method/process] By using the feedback intervention theory as an overarching framework, this paper integrated social cognition theory and flow theory and proposed a model to depict the influence of feedback type and feedback valence on volunteers' experience and performance in citizen science projects. This study also discussed the interaction effects between feedback type and feedback valence. A 2 (feedback type:descriptive vs. evaluative)×2 (feedback valence:positive vs. negative) between-subject experiment was conducted to validate the proposed research model.[Result/conclusion] Results showed that feedback type and feedback valence have varying impact on volunteers' experience. Volunteers had higher self-efficacy in evaluative feedback than in descriptive feedback; and they had higher self-efficacy and flow experience in positive feedback than in negative feedback. Moreover, there was a statistically significant interaction between feedback type and feedback valence on self-efficacy. For negative feedback, volunteers had higher self-efficacy in evaluative feedback than in descriptive feedback. Volunteer's participation experience had a positive effect on participation performance.

周鑫雪、余美华、汤健

科学、科学研究自然科学研究方法自然科学教育、自然科学普及

公众科学反馈信息参与体验参与表现反馈干预

citizen sciencefeedback informationparticipation experienceparticipation performancefeedback intervention

周鑫雪,余美华,汤健.反馈信息类型与效价对公众科学志愿者参与表现激励效应的实验研究[EB/OL].(2023-04-01)[2025-08-16].https://chinaxiv.org/abs/202304.00612.点此复制

评论