Hoogsteen base pairs increase the susceptibility of double-stranded DNA to cytotoxic damage

Abstract As the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases are protected in double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), it is commonly assumed that deleterious alkylation damage to the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases predominantly occurs when DNA becomes single-stranded during replication and transcription. However, damage to the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases has been reported in dsDNA in vitro through mechanisms that are not understood. In addition, the extent of protection from methylation damage conferred by dsDNA relative to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) has not been quantified. Watson-Crick base-pairs in dsDNA exist in dynamic equilibrium with Hoogsteen base-pairs that expose the Watson-Crick faces of purine nucleobases to solvent. Whether this can influence the damage susceptibility of dsDNA remains unknown. Using dot-blot and primer extension assays, we measured the susceptibility of adenine-N1 to methylation by dimethyl sulfate (DMS) when in an A-T Watson-Crick versus Hoogsteen conformation. Relative to unpaired adenines in a bulge, Watson-Crick A-T base-pairs in dsDNA only conferred ~130-fold protection against adenine-N1 methylation and this protection was reduced to ~40-fold for A(syn)-T Hoogsteen base-pairs embedded in a DNA-drug complex. Our results indicate that Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases are accessible to alkylating agents in canonical dsDNA and that Hoogsteen base-pairs increase this accessibility. Given the higher abundance of dsDNA relative to ssDNA, these results suggest that dsDNA could be a substantial source of cytotoxic damage. The work establishes DMS probing as a method for characterizing A(syn)-T Hoogsteen base pairs in vitro and also lays the foundation for a sequencing approach to map A(syn)-T Hoogsteen and unpaired adenines genome-wide in vivo.