|国家预印本平台
首页|基于几何形态测量学的刘氏蝎蛉翅形分析

基于几何形态测量学的刘氏蝎蛉翅形分析

Geometric Morphometric Approach of Wing Shape Variation of Colour Polymorphs in the Scorpionfly Panorpa liui Hua (Mecoptera: Panorpidae)

中文摘要英文摘要

许多昆虫呈现不同的体色,从而有利于适应不同的环境、迷惑捕食者等。这种现象被称为体色多型 (colour polymorphism),是造成分类学上同物异名的主要原因之一。刘氏蝎蛉 (Panorpa liui Hua, 1998) 是一种广泛分布于中国东北地区的蝎蛉科昆虫,原始记录中它的腹部呈现均一的黄色。然而在刘氏蝎蛉的分布区域内,我们采集到一些蝎蛉,其腹部呈均一棕黑色(黑体型蝎蛉),或生殖器节呈棕黑色而腹部其他部分是黄色(黑尾型蝎蛉)。黑体型蝎蛉、黑尾型蝎蛉与刘氏蝎蛉在许多分类特征上都有相似之处且分布域也存在重叠。本文以长白山蝎蛉 (Panorpa changbaishana)、刘氏蝎蛉 (P. liui) 和吉林蝎蛉 (P. jilinensis) 为参照,对所采集的未知样本黑尾型蝎蛉和黑体型蝎蛉的昆虫翅进行几何形态测量学分析,包括典型变量分析 (canonical variance analysis, CVA)、组间主成分分析 (between-group principal component analysis, bgPCA)、主成分分析 (principal component analysis, PCA) 和多元方差分析 (shape MANOVA),分析结果均显示黑尾型蝎蛉和黑体型蝎蛉的翅形与刘氏蝎蛉的翅形最相似,尤其是黑体型蝎蛉很难与刘氏蝎蛉分开,而黑尾型蝎蛉比吉林蝎蛉更接近刘氏蝎蛉。通过F检验和重复抽样检测,发现黑体型蝎蛉和刘氏蝎蛉翅形之间的普氏距离最小。单因素方差分析 (ANOVA) 和多重比较后,结果显示黑体型蝎蛉和黑尾型蝎蛉的翅质心值相当,但都大于刘氏蝎蛉的翅。本文记述了刘氏蝎蛉、黑体型蝎蛉、黑尾型蝎蛉和吉林蝎蛉在翅形上的差异,而且成功地运用几何形态测量学方法来鉴定未知样本,区分体色多型的样本。本文还简要讨论了体色多型的成因以及与同物异名现象的联系。

olour polymorphism is a common phenomenon in many groups of insects. This phenomenon allows adaptation to different environments, and is also one of the main reasons for synonymy in insect taxonomy practices. The scorpionfly Panorpa liui Hua is a widespread species in the northeastern region of China, with a typical yellowish-brown body and ground colour of wings. However, a black-bodied Panorpa (melanic morph) and a black-tailed Panorpa (intermediate morph) are frequently encountered sympatrically with the typical brown morph of P. liui, to which they are very similar in appearance. Geometric morphometric analyses were conducted on the variation of the right forewing shape with P. changbaishana and P. jilinensis as reference species. The results show that the wing shapes of the intermediate and melanic morphs are very similar to and difficult to separate from that of the typical morph of P. liui based on the canonical variance analysis, between-group PCA (principal component analysis) and the PCA. The partial Procrustes distance between the melanic morph and the typical P. liui is the smallest, indicating that they are the most similar on wing shape. The melanic morph and the intermediate morph are nearly the same on wing size, and larger than the typical morph of P. liui. Differences in wing morphology are described for these three morphs and indicate that geometric morphometric analyses of wing characters accurately classify individuals of the unknown specimens and can reliably discriminate between colour polymorphism groups in specific level. The reason of colour polymorphism and its possibility of causing synonyms in taxonomy are briefly discussed.

姜碌、闫宝荣、花保祯、花远、冯艳艳

昆虫学

体色多型季节型几何形态测量学长翅目蝎蛉

olour polymorphismseasonal morphgeometric morphometricsMecopterascorpionfly

姜碌,闫宝荣,花保祯,花远,冯艳艳.基于几何形态测量学的刘氏蝎蛉翅形分析[EB/OL].(2014-06-05)[2025-08-24].http://www.paper.edu.cn/releasepaper/content/201406-98.点此复制

评论