Cross-species analysis between the maize smut fungi Ustilago maydis and Sporisorium reilianum highlights the role of transcriptional plasticity of effector orthologs for virulence and disease

Summary The constitution and regulation of effector repertoires determines and shapes the outcome of the interaction with the host. Ustilago maydis and Sporisorium reilianum are two closely related smut fungi, which both infect maize, but cause distinct disease symptoms. Understanding how effector orthologs are regulated in these two pathogens can therefore provide insights to pathogen evolution and host adaption.We tracked the infection progress of U. maydis and S. reilianum in maize leaves, characterized two distinct infection stages for cross species RNA-sequencing analysis and identified 207 out of 335 one-to-one effector orthologs being differentially regulated during host colonization, while transcriptional plasticity of the effector orthologs correlated with the distinct disease development strategies.By using CRISPR-Cas9 mediated gene conversion, we identified two differentially expressed effector orthologs with conserved function between two pathogens. Thus, differential expression of functionally conserved genes contributes to species specific adaptation and symptom development. Interestingly, another differentially expressed orthogroup (UMAG_05318/Sr1007) showed diverged protein function during speciation, providing a possible case for neofunctionalization.Collectively, we showed the diversification of effector genes in related pathogens can be caused both by plasticity on the transcriptional level, as well as through functional diversification of the encoded effector proteins.